Data lakes promised to solve enterprise data problems by storing everything cheaply and flexibly. Reality has been more complex—many organizations have created data swamps that are difficult to navigate and trust. Success requires architectural decisions that balance flexibility with governance.
This guide provides a framework for data lake architecture that delivers value.
Understanding Data Lake Concepts
Data Lake vs. Data Warehouse
Fundamental differences:
Data Lake:
- Schema-on-read: Structure applied when data is used
- Stores raw data in native format
- Supports diverse data types
- Flexible and exploratory
- Requires governance discipline
Data Warehouse:
- Schema-on-write: Structure applied when data enters
- Stores structured, transformed data
- Optimized for known queries
- More rigid but more governed
- Easier for business users
Modern Data Lakehouse
Emerging hybrid approach:
Best of both: Raw storage with structured query capabilities.
ACID transactions: Reliability guarantees on lake storage.
Schema evolution: Flexibility with structure.
Technologies: Delta Lake, Apache Iceberg, Apache Hudi.
Architecture Design
Zone Architecture
Organizing the data lake:
Landing/Raw zone:
- Data as received from sources
- Unmodified, full fidelity
- Historical archive
- Limited access
Curated/Refined zone:
- Cleaned and validated data
- Standard formats and schemas
- Quality assured
- Broader access
Consumption/Analytics zone:
- Business-ready datasets
- Aggregated and optimized
- Semantic layer definitions
- Self-service access
Sandbox/Exploration zone:
- Experimental work
- Data science development
- Limited governance
- Isolation from production
Data Organization
Structuring data within zones:
Partitioning: Organize by date, source, business unit.
File formats: Parquet for analytics, JSON for flexibility.
Naming conventions: Consistent, discoverable naming.
Metadata management: Catalog and document all data.
Technology Decisions
Storage Platform
Foundational choice:
Cloud object storage: S3, Azure Blob, GCS—standard for new builds.
Hadoop HDFS: Legacy, being replaced by cloud.
Hybrid approaches: Cloud storage with on-premise compute.
Compute Engines
Processing choices:
Spark: Dominant for large-scale processing.
Databricks: Unified platform approach.
Cloud-native: AWS Athena, Azure Synapse, BigQuery.
Specialized engines: Presto/Trino for interactive queries.
Data Catalog
Discovery and governance:
Technical metadata: Schema, lineage, quality metrics.
Business metadata: Definitions, ownership, sensitivity.
Technologies: AWS Glue, Purview, Alation, Collibra.
Governance Framework
Data Quality
Ensuring usability:
Validation rules: Automated quality checks.
Quality metrics: Completeness, accuracy, timeliness.
Quality monitoring: Continuous assessment.
Remediation processes: Addressing quality issues.
Security and Access
Protecting data:
Access control: Role-based, attribute-based access.
Encryption: At rest and in transit.
Audit logging: Track all access.
Data classification: Sensitivity-based handling.
Data Lineage
Understanding data flow:
Source tracking: Where did data come from?
Transformation tracking: How was it processed?
Impact analysis: What depends on this data?
Automated capture: Tool-based lineage collection.
Common Pitfalls
The Data Swamp
When lakes become unusable:
Symptoms: Can't find data, don't trust quality, unclear ownership.
Prevention: Strong governance from the start.
Remediation: Incremental cleanup, starting with high-value data.
Over-Engineering
Building more than needed:
Symptoms: Complex architecture, low utilization, extended timelines.
Prevention: Start simple, evolve with demand.
Balance: Architecture for current needs plus reasonable growth.
Key Takeaways
-
Governance from day one: Data swamps result from neglecting governance.
-
Zone architecture works: Landing → Curated → Consumption flow.
-
Lakehouse is the future: Combine lake flexibility with warehouse reliability.
-
Metadata is essential: Data you can't find or trust is worthless.
-
Start simple: Don't over-engineer before you have data and users.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should we build a data lake or warehouse? Modern practice: both (lakehouse). Start with clear use cases.
Which cloud should we use? Typically follows enterprise cloud strategy. All major clouds have strong offerings.
How do we migrate from existing data warehouses? Often complement rather than replace. Migrate gradually based on use case fit.
What about real-time data? Stream processing (Kafka, Kinesis) feeds the lake. Architecture supports both batch and streaming.
How do we ensure data quality at scale? Automated quality rules, monitoring, clear ownership, self-service quality tools.
What's the team structure for data lake management? Platform team for infrastructure, data engineering for pipelines, data governance for standards.